4 Best Gift Cards for Crafters That Inspire Creativity

Finding the perfect gift for a crafter can feel like navigating a maze of specialty tools, obscure materials, and personal preferences. What one maker considers essential, another might never touch. That's where gift cards shine – they put the power of choice directly in the crafter's hands.

The best gift cards for crafters go beyond simple purchasing power. They open doors to discovery, whether that's a new technique, an upgraded tool, or finally splurging on those premium supplies they've been eyeing. We've rounded up four standout options that creative minds consistently love.

Michaels Gift Cards, Amazon Gift Cards, Joann Fabric and Crafts Gift Cards and etc

1. Michaels Gift Cards

Michaels remains the go-to destination for crafters across skill levels and interests. Their gift cards work both in-store and online, giving recipients flexibility in how they shop.

What makes Michaels special: The sheer variety is impressive. From yarn and fabric to woodworking supplies and seasonal decorations, most crafters can find what they need under one roof. Their frequent sales and coupon system mean gift card dollars stretch further than face value.

Pros:

• Covers nearly every craft category imaginable
• Regular sales events maximize buying power
• In-store classes and workshops available
• Easy online ordering with store pickup options

Cons:

• Quality can vary significantly between product lines
• Stores sometimes feel cluttered and overwhelming
• Limited selection of high-end or professional-grade tools

Best for: Crafters who enjoy variety, beginners exploring different mediums, or anyone who loves a good deal.

2. Amazon Gift Cards

Amazon's massive marketplace makes their gift cards incredibly versatile for crafters. The selection ranges from basic supplies to specialized equipment that's hard to find locally.

Why crafters love Amazon: The convenience factor is huge. Need replacement blades for a rotary cutter at 10 PM? They've got it. Looking for that specific shade of embroidery floss? Probably in stock. Prime shipping means less waiting and more creating.

Pros:

• Massive selection includes hard-to-find specialty items
• Customer reviews help with purchasing decisions
• Fast shipping options keep projects moving
• Price comparison tools ensure good value

Cons:

• Can't touch or examine materials before buying
• Quality varies widely among third-party sellers
• Easy to get overwhelmed by too many choices
• Shipping costs can add up for non-Prime members

Best for: Crafters who know exactly what they want, those seeking specialty or international supplies, or anyone who values convenience.

3. Joann Fabric and Crafts Gift Cards

Joann has carved out a loyal following among sewers, quilters, and fabric enthusiasts. Their gift cards work in stores and online, often coinciding with their famous sales events.

What sets Joann apart: The fabric selection is genuinely impressive, and their cutting services save time and ensure accuracy. Staff members often have real crafting experience and can offer helpful advice. The store layout typically makes sense, unlike some competitors.

Pros:

• Excellent fabric quality and selection
• Knowledgeable staff who actually craft
• Regular sales and coupon offers
• Good selection of sewing machines and notions

Cons:

• Limited appeal for non-fabric crafts
• Fewer locations than some competitors
• Can be pricey without sales or coupons
• Online inventory doesn't always match in-store selection

Best for: Serious sewers and quilters, anyone working on home décor projects, or crafters who appreciate expert advice.

4. Etsy Gift Cards

Etsy gift cards open up a world of handmade supplies, vintage finds, and unique materials you won't find anywhere else. They're perfect for crafters who value originality and supporting small businesses.

The Etsy advantage: Where else can you find hand-dyed yarn from a farm in Vermont, vintage buttons from the 1940s, and custom leather stamps all in one place? Many sellers offer personalization or custom orders, making each purchase feel special.

Pros:

• Access to truly unique and handmade supplies
• Supports independent artisans and small businesses
• Custom and personalized options available
• Great for finding vintage or discontinued items

Cons:

• Shipping times vary widely between sellers
• Quality can be inconsistent
• Returns and exchanges are more complicated
• Prices may be higher than mass-market alternatives

Best for: Crafters who value uniqueness, those supporting handmade businesses, or anyone looking for supplies with character and history.

Making the Right Choice

The best gift card depends on the crafter's style and needs. Beginners often appreciate the variety and value at Michaels, while experienced makers might prefer Etsy's unique offerings. Amazon works well for specific supply runs, and Joann excels for fabric-focused projects.

Consider combining smaller amounts across multiple retailers – a $25 Michaels card paired with a $25 Etsy card gives more flexibility than $50 at one store. Many crafters enjoy the treasure hunt aspect of shopping different venues for the perfect materials.

No matter which option you choose, you're giving more than just purchasing power. You're providing the foundation for new projects, skill development, and creative expression. That's a gift that keeps inspiring long after the card balance reaches zero.

​4 Best Gift Cards for Crafters That Inspire Creativity

4 Best Gift Cards for Crafters That Inspire Creativity